Search
What are you looking for?
Start main content

Press Releases

Press Releases

https://www.med.cuhk.edu.hk/press-releases/cuhk-and-queen-mary-university-of-london-lead-largest-international-trial-of-time-lapse-imaging-systems-for-embryo-incubation-in-ivf-technology
https://www.med.cuhk.edu.hk/press-releases/cuhk-and-queen-mary-university-of-london-lead-largest-international-trial-of-time-lapse-imaging-systems-for-embryo-incubation-in-ivf-technology

CUHK and Queen Mary University of London lead largest international trial of time-lapse imaging systems for embryo incubation in IVF Technology found to enjoy no advantage over conventional methods

An international trial of time-lapse imaging (TLI) systems for embryo incubation and selection during in vitro fertilisation (IVF), co-led by the Assisted Reproductive Medicine Unit in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at The Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK)’ Faculty of Medicine (CU Medicine) and the Women’s Health Research Unit at Queen Mary University of London, has found that a TLI system gives no advantage in clinical outcomes over conventional methods although it offers a seamless process for monitoring embryo development. Researchers believe the findings provide insights that will allow for better allocation of resources and investment in future IVF services. The landmark findings of the largest international trial of its kind have been published in The Lancet.

 

Prof Poon, Prof Chan, Dr Chung

(From left) Professor Liona Poon Chiu-yee, Department Chairperson; Professor David Chan Yiu-leung, Assistant Professor; and Dr Jacqueline ChungPui-wah, Associate Professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at CU Medicine.

Continuous debates over the clinical effectiveness of TLI systems

 

embryo dishes

Featured in this photo are IVF embryo dish used in TLI system (left) and that of conventional method.

One out of six couples in Hong Kong experience fertility problems. IVF is the most common treatment allowing infertile couples to achieve pregnancy. Gametes from wife and husband are combined in an IVF laboratory to create the embryo, with a resulting good-quality embryo transferred to the mother’s womb, typically on the fifth day.

 

The conventional incubation method requires an embryologist to observe the embryo once per day. Moving the incubator in order to observe the embryo can potentially disturb the latter. In contrast, a TLI system, equipped with an internal camera for continuous observation without disturbance, offers a seamless monitoring process. While TLI has been a common practice in IVF labs for over a decade, its clinical effectiveness remains controversial. TLI systems are often associated with additional costs for patients due to high equipment expenses.

 

Professor David Chan Yiu-leung, an embryologist from the Department Obstetrics and Gynaecology at CU Medicine, and Dr Priya Bhide, an expert in reproductive medicine from Queen Mary, led this three-arm, parallel-group, double-blind, randomised, controlled trial of 1,500 participants undergoing IVF at seven centres in Hong Kong and the UK. Hong Kong contributed to one-third of the cases in this study. One group of participants received TLI-based embryo selection, one received standard static assessment using undisturbed culture and a third received conventional assessment using a light microscope and standard embryo culture in standard incubators. Results showed no significant difference among three groups in the live birth rates for embryos and clinical pregnancy rates. (Please refer to Table 1 for details)

 

Embryo diary

 

Professor Liona Poon Chiu-yee, Chairperson of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at CU Medicine, said: “Our department encourages randomised controlled trial studies to support evidence-based medicine refuting hypothetical benefits without proven clinical outcomes. We are dedicated to providing accurate treatment choices and the highest level of care to our patients. The concept of ‘non-disturb culturing’ has been widely accepted as a better procedure by IVF specialists. This study proved that theoretical concepts of advanced technology do not always translate into improved clinical outcomes.”

 

Professor David Chan Yiu-leung, Assistant Professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at CU Medicine, said: “Although TLI is an important equipment in IVF labs, it does not improve IVF clinical outcomes. Patients seeking IVF treatment should be vigilant about fees for embryo culturing, as clinics might impose additional fees for the use of TLI.”

 

Dr Jacqueline Chung Pui-wah, Associate Professor in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at CU Medicine, said: “The findings from this study could prompt IVF clinics to reconsider how they allocate their budget for equipment. Instead of investing heavily in TLI machines, they could focus more on lab equipment that has a direct, measurable impact on live birth rates."

 

The study was supported by the Health and Medical Research Fund and other funding.

 

Table 1: Clinical outcomes among three embryo incubation and selection methods in the study

 

Live birth rates for embryos

 

Clinical pregnancy rates

TLI-based embryo selection1

 

33.7%

42.2%

Standard static assessment using undisturbed culture2

 

36.6%

43.4%

Conventional assessment using a light microscope and

standard embryo culture in standard incubators3

33.0%

40.9%

++No significance difference in statistics in the live birth rates for embryos and clinical pregnancy rates among three methods++

 

1 Participants assigned to TLI-based embryo selection had embryo assessment and selection based on the morphological embryo scoring provided by the system.

2 Participants assigned to this method had only conventional morphological embryo assessment performed by embryologists in undisturbed culture conditions in the TLI system.

3 This method serves as control group, with participants receiving conventional morphological embryo assessment performed by embryologists using the light microscope and standard embryo culture in standard incubators.   

 

More Press Releases

CUHK Launches World’s First Study on Ovum Ageing and Female Infertility by Using Single-Cell Genomics Technology

CUHK Launches World’s First Study on Ovum Ageing and Female Infertility by Using Single-Cell Genomics Technology

Research
CUHK leads multi-centre Asian study showing that an early screen-and-prevent strategy for preterm preeclampsia is effective at lowering risk of complications for high-risk women by 41%  Pilot service at Prince of Wales Hospital showed promising outcome

CUHK leads multi-centre Asian study showing that an early screen-and-prevent strategy for preterm preeclampsia is effective at lowering risk of complications for high-risk women by 41% Pilot service at Prince of Wales Hospital showed promising outcome

Research
CU Medicine’s Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Unit preserves the reproductive ability of cancer patients in Hong Kong

CU Medicine’s Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) Unit preserves the reproductive ability of cancer patients in Hong Kong

Research
CUHK and FPAHK launch the Jockey Club Genetic Carrier Screening Programme for High Risk Couples

CUHK and FPAHK launch the Jockey Club Genetic Carrier Screening Programme for High Risk Couples

Health Campaign
CUHK finds that a booster vaccine dose is effective in retriggering antibodies in breast milk that protect babies

CUHK finds that a booster vaccine dose is effective in retriggering antibodies in breast milk that protect babies

Research
CUHK-Baylor Study Proves Aspirin Reduces the Risk of Preeclampsia by Decelerating the Metabolic Clock of Gestation

CUHK-Baylor Study Proves Aspirin Reduces the Risk of Preeclampsia by Decelerating the Metabolic Clock of Gestation

Research
CU Medicine Study Shows Recovered Mothers Transfer COVID-19 Antibodies to Newborn Babies

CU Medicine Study Shows Recovered Mothers Transfer COVID-19 Antibodies to Newborn Babies

Research
CUHK Proves Modified HIFU Treatment Effective for Treating Uterine Fibroids

CUHK Proves Modified HIFU Treatment Effective for Treating Uterine Fibroids

Research
CUHK Pioneers Whole Genome Sequencing for Identifying the Chromosomal Abnormalities in Couples with Recurrent Miscarriages

CUHK Pioneers Whole Genome Sequencing for Identifying the Chromosomal Abnormalities in Couples with Recurrent Miscarriages

Research
Chinese Women with Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome have 4-fold Higher Risk of Developing Diabetes

Chinese Women with Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome have 4-fold Higher Risk of Developing Diabetes

Research
CUHK Validates the Enhanced UK Fetal Medicine Foundation’s Triple Test Can Double the Detection Rate of Preterm Preeclampsia in Asian Pregnant Women

CUHK Validates the Enhanced UK Fetal Medicine Foundation’s Triple Test Can Double the Detection Rate of Preterm Preeclampsia in Asian Pregnant Women

Research
CUHK Pioneers Whole Genome Sequencing for Prenatal Diagnosis in Hong Kong

CUHK Pioneers Whole Genome Sequencing for Prenatal Diagnosis in Hong Kong

Research
CUHK Studies Alert Mothers to Pregnancy Weight Gain

CUHK Studies Alert Mothers to Pregnancy Weight Gain

Research
CUHK Recommends Oral Glucose Tolerance Test for All Pregnant Women Study Reveals Children of Women with Gestational Diabetes Mellitus Have 3-Fold Diabetes Risk

CUHK Recommends Oral Glucose Tolerance Test for All Pregnant Women Study Reveals Children of Women with Gestational Diabetes Mellitus Have 3-Fold Diabetes Risk

Research
CUHK Launches Newborn Add-on Test for Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Supported by Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease

CUHK Launches Newborn Add-on Test for Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Supported by Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease

Donation
CUHK Reveals Hepatitis B Prevalence Among Pregnant Women Remains High Despite More Than 25 Years of Universal Hepatitis B Vaccination

CUHK Reveals Hepatitis B Prevalence Among Pregnant Women Remains High Despite More Than 25 Years of Universal Hepatitis B Vaccination

Research
CUHK Reveals Vasopressin Injection Can Reduce Risks of Hysteroscopic Myomectomy

CUHK Reveals Vasopressin Injection Can Reduce Risks of Hysteroscopic Myomectomy

Research
CUHK Found Common Defect in Male Infertility Associated with Poor Sperm Motility and Genital Tract Infection

CUHK Found Common Defect in Male Infertility Associated with Poor Sperm Motility and Genital Tract Infection

Research
CUHK and Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease Jointly Launch Territory’s First Newborn Metabolic Screening Program

CUHK and Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease Jointly Launch Territory’s First Newborn Metabolic Screening Program

Donation
CUHK Introduces Hong Kong's First Fragile X Carrier Screening

CUHK Introduces Hong Kong's First Fragile X Carrier Screening

Clinical service
CUHK and US Experts Collaborate to Provide Clinical Genetic Training to Set up The Territory's First One-Stop Outpatient Genetic Clinic

CUHK and US Experts Collaborate to Provide Clinical Genetic Training to Set up The Territory's First One-Stop Outpatient Genetic Clinic

International collaboration
CUHK Pioneers DNA Chip for Prenatal Diagnosis in HK

CUHK Pioneers DNA Chip for Prenatal Diagnosis in HK

Research

Our Expert List

Many experts under the Faculty of Medicine are available for media interview.
Please click here for the expert list or contact us.