Search
What are you looking for?
Start main content

Press Releases

Press Releases

https://www.med.cuhk.edu.hk/press-releases/cuhk-study-suggests-a-standardised-experimental-setup-is-the-key-to-optimise-performance-of-covid-19-nucleic-acid-tests
https://www.med.cuhk.edu.hk/press-releases/cuhk-study-suggests-a-standardised-experimental-setup-is-the-key-to-optimise-performance-of-covid-19-nucleic-acid-tests

CUHK Study Suggests a Standardised Experimental Setup is the Key to Optimise Performance of COVID-19 Nucleic Acid Tests

To ensure the accuracy and consistency of diagnostic tests for COVID-19 is an important aspect in effective disease control. The Faculty of Medicine at The Chinese University of Hong Kong (CU Medicine) systematically evaluated the performance of three common nucleic acid tests, namely digital Polymerase Chain Reaction (dPCR), quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction (qPCR), and loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP), for the diagnosis of COVID-19 in hospital and clinics. Results demonstrated that though dPCR is the most sensitive type of test, followed by qPCR, and then LAMP, there was no significant difference in the accuracy or consistency among the three types of test. Instead, researchers found that the specimen types and RNA extraction methods should be the focus in optimising the tests performance. The findings have been published in the international prestigious journal The Lancet Microbe.

 

PCR as the current gold standard while LAMP emerging as alternative for rapid COVID-19 test

 

PCR is the most widely used diagnostic method for COVID-19 infection worldwide. Referred to as qPCR or RT-PCR, the technology is highly sensitive and considered the gold standard for coronavirus screening. In Hong Kong, PCR is the type of nucleic acid test being offered in government recognised COVID-19 testing institutions. dPCR is a novel technology developed to facilitate the diagnosis of COVID-19 that allows absolute quantification of nucleic acids in hospitals and diagnostic centres, meaning physicians can extract more information from its superior sensitivity.

 

LAMP test is gaining popularity as a rapid test which can yield results within an hour, as opposed to the four- to six-hour minimum return currently required for a PCR test. It has emerged as a popular alternative to qPCR in rapid testing environments such as airports and testing centres worldwide. Researchers’ findings showed that LAMP is a time-saving and reliable testing technique comparable to the currently used PCR test. The application of LAMP in mass-screening will mitigate the bottleneck of PCR testing in Hong Kong.

 

Professor Peter Pak Hang CHEUNG, Assistant Professor of the Department of Chemical Pathology and Investigator of Li Ka Shing Institute of Health Sciences at CU Medicine said, “We believe it is of great importance and urgency to conduct a comprehensive review that systematically compares all common nucleic acid tests and accounts for different experimental setups”. The three tests have been evaluated individually in cohort and trial studies using clinical samples. Interestingly, experimental setups affect virus detection accuracy more so than assay types.

 

Pharyngeal swabs should remain the gold standard for diagnosing COVID-19

 

The research team included 66 studies (11 dPCR, 32 qPCR, and 23 LAMP) with 15,017 clinical samples in total in their systematic review and 52 studies in meta-analysis. Below are the key findings:

 

  • dPCR is the most sensitive, followed by quantitative qPCR and LAMP
  • High sensitivity of dPCR agrees with the extremely low and consistent detection limits of the test
  • In the subgroup analysis for specimens, all three tests using pharyngeal swabs consistently show higher sensitivity and accuracy than saliva
  • The three nucleic acid tests using open reading frame 1ab primer outperform the same tests using nucleocapsid primer
  • All RNA-extracted samples result in a more accurate test performance than crude samples regardless of which RNA extraction method is applied

 

Professor Cheung explained, “We observed that when controlling the experimental setup of each test by specifying the primer- probe set, RNA extraction, and specimen type, the accuracy estimated did not differ across different nucleic acid tests. However, significant variations in accuracy were observed when the experimental setup was changed. This implies that optimisation efforts should be directed towards designing a robust and consistent experimental setup as the accuracy of SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid tests is more strongly dependent on the experimental setup than on the type of test used.”

 

“Our results also agreed with US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and WHO’s recommendations to use pharyngeal swabs over saliva. Overall, the three nucleic acid tests performed the most accurately and consistently with pharyngeal swabs using SARS-CoV-2 open reading frame 1ab primer with RNA extraction. Our study suggests that the test type can be selected according to the environmental and socioeconomic requirements, as long as the optimal experimental setup is implemented and standardised,” he added.  

 

Ms. Wing Yan AU and Prof. Peter Cheung

Professor Peter Pak Hang CHEUNG, Assistant Professor of the Department of Chemical Pathology and Investigator of Li Ka Shing Institute of Health Sciences (right), and Ms. Wing Yan AU, first author of the study and MPhil student of the Department of Chemical Pathology at CU Medicine.

More Press Releases

Joint CUHK-HKU study discovers efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines correlates with a probiotic bacterium, Bifidobacterium adolescentis

Joint CUHK-HKU study discovers efficacy of COVID-19 vaccines correlates with a probiotic bacterium, Bifidobacterium adolescentis

Research
CU Medicine Survey Shows Only 25% of Unvaccinated People Intend to Get Inoculated in the Coming Six Months “Multiple Incentives” are Urgently Needed

CU Medicine Survey Shows Only 25% of Unvaccinated People Intend to Get Inoculated in the Coming Six Months “Multiple Incentives” are Urgently Needed

Research
CUHK study sheds light on novel mechanism and treatment of acute kidney injury in COVID-19 patients

CUHK study sheds light on novel mechanism and treatment of acute kidney injury in COVID-19 patients

Research
Three CU Medicine scholars named in world’s “Top 20 Translational Researchers” Professor Dennis LO receives the honour for the fifth consecutive year

Three CU Medicine scholars named in world’s “Top 20 Translational Researchers” Professor Dennis LO receives the honour for the fifth consecutive year

Awards and honors
CUHK Study Demonstrates a 2.5-fold Increase in Myopia Incidence in Children  During COVID-19 Pandemic Due to Less Time Outdoors and More Time on Screens

CUHK Study Demonstrates a 2.5-fold Increase in Myopia Incidence in Children During COVID-19 Pandemic Due to Less Time Outdoors and More Time on Screens

Research
CU Medicine Estimates 20,000 COVID-19 Hidden Infections in Hong Kong  All Vaccinated Persons in HK Developed Neutralising Antibody After Two Doses  Urgent Call for the Largely Unprotected Population to Get Vaccinated

CU Medicine Estimates 20,000 COVID-19 Hidden Infections in Hong Kong All Vaccinated Persons in HK Developed Neutralising Antibody After Two Doses Urgent Call for the Largely Unprotected Population to Get Vaccinated

Research
A Global Study Led by CU Medicine and HKUMed Discovers  a Hepatitis C Virus Drug as Potent Treatment for COVID-19

A Global Study Led by CU Medicine and HKUMed Discovers a Hepatitis C Virus Drug as Potent Treatment for COVID-19

Research
CUHK Develops a Computational Platform to Predict Vaccine Effectiveness by Virus Genome

CUHK Develops a Computational Platform to Predict Vaccine Effectiveness by Virus Genome

Research
CU Medicine Study Shows Recovered Mothers Transfer COVID-19 Antibodies to Newborn Babies

CU Medicine Study Shows Recovered Mothers Transfer COVID-19 Antibodies to Newborn Babies

Research
CU Medicine Study Suggests Toddlers are at High Risk of Being  “Silent Spreaders of SARS-CoV2 Infection”

CU Medicine Study Suggests Toddlers are at High Risk of Being “Silent Spreaders of SARS-CoV2 Infection”

Research
CU Medicine Study Shows Modulation of Gut Microbiota  Helps Enhance Safety and Efficacy of COVID-19 Vaccine

CU Medicine Study Shows Modulation of Gut Microbiota Helps Enhance Safety and Efficacy of COVID-19 Vaccine

Research
CU Medicine and International Surgeons Suggest Patients with Positive COVID-19 Results Should Delay Surgery for Seven Weeks to Reduce Death Risk

CU Medicine and International Surgeons Suggest Patients with Positive COVID-19 Results Should Delay Surgery for Seven Weeks to Reduce Death Risk

International collaboration
CU Medicine Finds New Evidence for Link between Gut Microbiome and COVID-19 Severity Microbiome Imbalance Might Influence “Long COVID” Risk

CU Medicine Finds New Evidence for Link between Gut Microbiome and COVID-19 Severity Microbiome Imbalance Might Influence “Long COVID” Risk

Research
CU Medicine Survey Shows Government Recommendation as the Strongest Driver for COVID-19 Vaccine Acceptance

CU Medicine Survey Shows Government Recommendation as the Strongest Driver for COVID-19 Vaccine Acceptance

Research
CUHK Introduces Nasal Strip Sampling for COVID-19 Test As a Superior Tool for Surveillance in a Wide Age-Range Population

CUHK Introduces Nasal Strip Sampling for COVID-19 Test As a Superior Tool for Surveillance in a Wide Age-Range Population

Research
40% of Hong Kong People Show Gut Dysbiosis Comparable to that of COVID-19 Patients CUHK Microbiome Immunity Formula Hastens Recovery of COVID-19 Patients and Offers Hope to Boost Immunity

40% of Hong Kong People Show Gut Dysbiosis Comparable to that of COVID-19 Patients CUHK Microbiome Immunity Formula Hastens Recovery of COVID-19 Patients and Offers Hope to Boost Immunity

Research
CUHK Study Shows Exposure Settings Impact COVID-19 Transmission With Entertainment Setting Showing Propensity for Widespread Dispersion

CUHK Study Shows Exposure Settings Impact COVID-19 Transmission With Entertainment Setting Showing Propensity for Widespread Dispersion

Research
CU Medicine Found SARS-CoV2 in Infants' Stool A Coronavirus Testing Centre Is Established for Paediatric Population to Identify Silent Carriers

CU Medicine Found SARS-CoV2 in Infants' Stool A Coronavirus Testing Centre Is Established for Paediatric Population to Identify Silent Carriers

Research
Most Deaths from COVID-19 in Hong Kong are of 60 Years Old or Above CUHK Initiated International Effort in Devising Strategies to Protect Older People with Dementia amid COVID-19 Pandemic

Most Deaths from COVID-19 in Hong Kong are of 60 Years Old or Above CUHK Initiated International Effort in Devising Strategies to Protect Older People with Dementia amid COVID-19 Pandemic

Research
CU Medicine Study Shows Liver Injury is Common and Prognostic in COVID-19 Patients

CU Medicine Study Shows Liver Injury is Common and Prognostic in COVID-19 Patients

Research
CUHK Researchers Uncover Diabetes as a Potential Risk Factor for COVID-19,  and Possible Mechanisms

CUHK Researchers Uncover Diabetes as a Potential Risk Factor for COVID-19, and Possible Mechanisms

Research
CU Medicine Survey Shows Global Urological Services have been Significantly Deferred due to COVID-19 Pandemic

CU Medicine Survey Shows Global Urological Services have been Significantly Deferred due to COVID-19 Pandemic

Research
CU Medicine Develops a Probiotic Formula to Target Imbalance in Gut Microbiota in COVID-19

CU Medicine Develops a Probiotic Formula to Target Imbalance in Gut Microbiota in COVID-19

Research
CU Medicine Recruits 3,000 Persons to Investigate Hidden Infection and Break the Obstacles in Containing COVID-19 in Hong Kong

CU Medicine Recruits 3,000 Persons to Investigate Hidden Infection and Break the Obstacles in Containing COVID-19 in Hong Kong

Research
CU Medicine Offers Free Stool Screening Test for COVID-19 in Children arriving at Airport

CU Medicine Offers Free Stool Screening Test for COVID-19 in Children arriving at Airport

Clinical service
CUHK Finds that the Coronavirus Can Persist in Stool after Its Clearance in Respiratory Tract Will Conduct Stool Test for People in Quarantine Camps for Early Identification

CUHK Finds that the Coronavirus Can Persist in Stool after Its Clearance in Respiratory Tract Will Conduct Stool Test for People in Quarantine Camps for Early Identification

Research
CU Medicine Announces the Community Response Study Results During the Early Phase of the COVID-19 Outbreak in Hong Kong

CU Medicine Announces the Community Response Study Results During the Early Phase of the COVID-19 Outbreak in Hong Kong

Research
CUHK-Designed Intervention Package Proves Effective to Increase Influenza Vaccine Uptake in Hong Kong Young Children

CUHK-Designed Intervention Package Proves Effective to Increase Influenza Vaccine Uptake in Hong Kong Young Children

Research
CUHK Reveals the Key to a Successful HPV Vaccination Programme

CUHK Reveals the Key to a Successful HPV Vaccination Programme

Research
CUHK Completes a 20,000-person Plasma DNA Screening Study of Nasopharyngeal Cancer, and Finds a Dramatic Shift to Early Stage Cancers

CUHK Completes a 20,000-person Plasma DNA Screening Study of Nasopharyngeal Cancer, and Finds a Dramatic Shift to Early Stage Cancers

Research
CUHK Proves Rotavirus Vaccine Highly Effective for HK Children

CUHK Proves Rotavirus Vaccine Highly Effective for HK Children

Research
CUHK Launches Newborn Add-on Test for Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Supported by Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease

CUHK Launches Newborn Add-on Test for Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia Supported by Joshua Hellmann Foundation for Orphan Disease

Donation
CUHK Research Reveals New Influenza Vaccine Offers More Effective Control over Influenza in Hong Kong

CUHK Research Reveals New Influenza Vaccine Offers More Effective Control over Influenza in Hong Kong

Research
CUHK Professor Rossa Chiu Awarded Chinese Young Women in Science Fellowship Latest Research Breakthrough – Blood DNA Sequencing to Scan for Cancers

CUHK Professor Rossa Chiu Awarded Chinese Young Women in Science Fellowship Latest Research Breakthrough – Blood DNA Sequencing to Scan for Cancers

Awards and honors
Young Female Scientist Excels in International Arena CUHK Professor Rossa Chiu Scoops Two Research Awards

Young Female Scientist Excels in International Arena CUHK Professor Rossa Chiu Scoops Two Research Awards

Awards and honors

Our Expert List

Many experts under the Faculty of Medicine are available for media interview.
Please click here for the expert list or contact us.